Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Germany. Show all posts

Friday, March 29, 2024

The Riddle of the Sands (1979)

In 1901, Arthur Davies (Simon MacCorkindale) is sailing his yacht along the Frisian Islands on the German coast.  Another yacht takes note of him and soon a young lady arrives to invite him for dinner.  She is Clara Dollman (Jenny Agutter), a German girl who speaks excellent English.  Arthur accepts the invitation and meets Clara's father and step-mother.  Herr Dollman is particularly interested in Davies' activities and reacts with something like alarm when Davies reveals that he is mapping the islands and sandbars.  Davies is convinced something peculiar is afoot and sends a letter to his old school chum, Charles Carruthers (Michael York), who speaks fluent German and has a junior post in the foreign office.  Carruthers is an aristocrat and, as such, is immediately put-off by Davies' tiny yacht.  Moreover, he thinks that Davies has no reason to be suspicious of Dollman.  However, he changes his view when he also provokes alarmed reactions from German officers.  What are the Germans doing?

The movie is something of a spy thriller, with the two young Englishmen poking their noses where they don't belong.  There is a good story here but it comes off mostly dull in this telling.  Davies' growing relationship with Clara is not allowed to flourish once Carruthers arrives.  Clara is left as a side character with little to do and only interacts with Davies in Carruthers' presence: awkward.  Davies and Carruthers should have been fused into one character, especially since most of the excitement sees one or the other infiltrating a factory or fleeing soldiers or fighting sailors.  The chemistry between the two is good and their banter is fun, but it distracts from the thriller aspects of the story.  Rather than opening and closing narration, the movie should have bookended the story with the discussed Royal visit between Kaiser Wilhelm (Wolf Kahler) and King Edward VII.  Open all cordial and jovial before Edward gets a stern look where he says they must discuss something.  Insert the action of Davies and Carruthers.  Return to the meeting where Wilhelm is now pale.  Show, don't tell, especially in a movie.

The most interesting thing about the movie is that it was based on a 1903 book, which warned against a German assault on the English coast.  More than a decade before the Great War, Erskine Childers saw conflict coming between the two nations.

It is just okay.

Wednesday, July 11, 2018

The End of NATO?

President Trump openly and undiplomatically hammered NATO members for failing to pay the portion of GDP toward defense that the treaty specified.  The US has shouldered the majority of European defense since the end of World War II.  Of course, NATO was formed as a bulwark against the Soviet Union, which collapsed over a quarter of a century ago.  Why not declare victory and go home?
 
With Russia supposedly a rising power, the US needs to stay in Europe to protect the West from Putin.  Failure to do so just proves that Trump is Putin's stooge!  Really?  It might come as a surprise that the German economy is more than 2 1/2 times the size of Russia's.  The UK is 2.1 times as large.  France's economy is double.  Italy is 1.5 times the Russian economy.  As a whole, the European Union has a Gross Domestic Product that is 13 times the size of the Russian economy.  The EU can easily dominate Russia but has instead mostly disarmed to maintain generous nanny states, outsourcing defense to the US taxpayer.  To top it off, we have trade deficits with most of them.  With allies like these...
 
27 years after the Cold War ended, there is no reason for the United States to still be defending Europeans from an economic backwater.  Worse, Europe is funding Russia by getting 40% of its energy from Putin.  Germany's dependence on Russian oil and gas is higher still.  Russia is a vital trade partner to modern Europe but NATO was formed to be anti-Russian.
 
No government ever voluntarily reduces itself in size.  Government programs, once launched, never disappear.  Actually, a government bureau is the nearest thing to eternal life we'll ever see on this earth!
Ronald Reagan
 
NATO is an expensive ($946 billion in 2017) relic of the Cold War, a governmental bureaucracy that completed its purpose but failed to close up shop.  Let's stick around for the 'attack on one is an attack on all' but nix the shared funding bit.  It's one thing to agree to come to your neighbor's aid if he is attacked and another to be unpaid security while he has a party.  The EU is a nuclear power (UK and France) and can afford to pay for its defense.  We'll be there if needed but it's time for them to pay the day to day costs.
No government ever voluntarily reduces itself in size. Government programs, once launched, never disappear. Actually, a government bureau is the nearest thing to eternal life we'll ever see on this earth!
Read more at: https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/ronald_reagan_147680