Showing posts with label Palestine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Palestine. Show all posts

Sunday, September 13, 2026

Palestinian-Israeli Conflict 101

The podcast provides some background of the conflict from 4000 years ago until the modern day.  It is broken into 3 parts, each about 45 to 50 minutes in length.  The narrator does an excellent job of being neutral in the conflict.  She announced from the start that it was meant to inform those who know next to nothing of the conflict and is merely a primer.

Part 1: 4,000 years ago to 1917.  Our story begins with Abraham, whose sons are the putative ancestors of the conflicting parties.  Jews trace their ancestry to Isaac while Muslims trace theirs to Ishmael.  The Jews lived in the region that is now Israel for hundreds of years, interrupted by the all too frequent conquest by a more powerful state.  However, the Romans grew tired of Jewish rebellions and deported many Jews from the area; this was the Jewish Diaspora.  Moreover, the Romans renamed the region to Palestine.  Though there were still Jews in the region, they were a minority.  Time passed and the Romans were replaced by the Byzantines who were replaced by a series of Muslim caliphates.  Then the Crusades conquered the area, briefly, before Egyptian Sultanate took over.  In turn, the Ottoman Empire ruled from the 16th century.  Meanwhile, Jews in Europe were suffering pogroms and needed somewhere to go.  In the 19th century, many migrated to Palestine.  During World War I, the British proposed a homeland for the Jews in the Balfour Declaration (1917).  That was not popular among the resident Muslim population.

Part 2: 1917 to 1967.  In the wake of World War I, the Ottoman Empire - which was on the losing side - had its territory divided among the victors.  The British acquired what is now Israel along with the growing tensions between the Jewish and Muslim residents.  There was a lot of unpleasantness between the wars.  Then World War II came.  Jews in Europe sought to escape to Palestine but were largely foiled.  After the war, they flooded in and Britain decided to split the territory in two and bug out.  Immediately, there was war between the Jews and the Muslims.  The Jews fared far better, claiming the majority of the territory.  Many Palestinians who had fled during the conflict demanded the right to return to their homes now that the fighting was ended.  Denied.  Instead, those homes were provided to the incoming flood of Holocaust survivors.  In the 1960s, Egyptian President Nasser threatened to destroy Israel, stating it had no right to exist.  He put troops in the Sinai Peninsula and prepared to attack.

Part 3: 1967 to 2023.  Taking Nasser at his word, the Israeli Airforce attacked Egypt, disabling its airforce and making its ground-based force in the empty desert an easy target.  The Israeli Airforce likewise bombed Jordan and Syria.  This was the Six-Day War and saw Israel capture the Sinai Peninsula, the Gaza Strip, the West Bank, and the Golan Heights.   Egypt and Syria took another crack at Israel in 1973's Yom Kippur War.  In 1978, President Carter hosted a peace conference between Egypt and Israel which resulted in Egypt recognizing Israel, a first for an Arab country.  At this point, the Palestinians, who had been in the wilderness for 4 decades now, gave up hope of being restored by neighboring co-religionists and took matters into their hands.  The PLO and similar groups emerged to fight by other means: terrorism.  In the 1990s, the Oslo Accords were negotiated but never fully implemented; it was another effort at a two-state solution going back to dividing the region like the British tried during the Mandate period.  Since then, there have been a series of Intafadas (uprisings) as well as Israel trading land for peace (evacuation of Gaza, some of the West Bank).

The podcast was released in August and September of 2023.  On October 7, 2023, the latest and most dramatic Intafada took place.

As mentioned, the narrator sought to be neutral regarding the conflict, offering the reasons each side views their position as superior.  She points out that atrocities have been committed by each side and each has been dispossessed of homes in the area.  She does not delve into the religions, giving each equal merit.  She does not delve into the governmental systems, again offering equal merit.  By ignoring the differing character of the competing peoples, it is easier to stay neutral on who should prevail.

Recommended.

Friday, August 28, 2026

DSA: Foreign Policy

Where Thriving Communities concerned itself with domestic policy, the DSA also has plans on how to handle international relations.  Let's return to the DSA website.

Working-Class Foreign Policy

End the U.S. War Machine: Defund the Department of War. End all foreign wars and close overseas military bases. Support and fully employ veterans. End immunity for U.S. war criminals and support the International Criminal Court's mandate to prosecute war crimes.

This is a prescription for national suicide.  How does the US defend itself without a military?  Who will fill the vacuum left by a US withdrawal from all overseas bases and a dismantling of the US Navy?  Who will determine which Americans are war criminals that need to be prosecuted in the ICC?  A call for unilateral disarmament is an invitation for hostile nations to invade.

Free Palestine: Recognize the rights of the Palestinian people, including the right of return, the right to resist military occupation, and the right to self determination in a free Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital. End all military and economic aid to Israel. Prosecute U.S. and Israeli leaders responsible for the genocide in Gaza.

Why doesn't anyone call for Free Tibet?  Or how about Free Kurdistan?  Free East Oregon?  No, it is always about the Palestinians.  Where Tibet is under the thumb of China, Kurdistan is dominated by Turkey, Iraq, and Iran, and East Oregon is oppressed by Salem, it is the Jews who are blamed for Palestine.  Yes, those rascally Israelis are uniquely evil and require a statement in DSA foreign policy.  Nevermind that the Palestinians always start the wars which result in the Israelis implementing defensive measures that further restrict the Palestinians.  Basically, until Israel is eliminated, Palestine is not free.  Understand that and you understand the whole Israel-Palestine conflict.  DSA wants the destruction of Israel.

End Blockades, Embargoes, and Sanctions: People around the world deserve to live their lives without U.S. interference. End economic warfare against countries whose governments act independently of the United States, such as Cuba, Venezuela, and Iran.

Stop making life difficult for those who hate us and wish our destruction.  Yes, what an obvious plan.  Let's make nice with communist Cuba (clearly, DSA is sympathetic to communists), ease up on narco-state Venezuela, and let the Mullahs of Iran resume their title of leading state sponsor of terrorism.  We've gotten rid of the military, so let's also get rid of our economic tools for fighting hostile powers.  Can't wait for those Iranian missiles to get installed in Cuba.  This time, there will be no missile crisis because we have ended blockading and defunded the navy that would implement the blockade.  I'm sure it will be fine.

Abolish ICE: End ICE detention and deportations and punish federal agents' brutality. Legalize migration, grant amnesty for all immigrants regardless of status, provide a path to citizenship for all permanent residents, and end visa caps and quotas.

Throw open the borders!  Let everyone in and grant them amnesty.  A country without borders soon ceases to be a country.  Combined with the policies outlined in Thriving Communities, the US - which is already under heavy financial strain - will be bankrupt in months.  If it survives that long.  With the borders open and the military defunded, what is to stop a flood of hostiles from sweeping into the country?

Are there people who are stupid enough to believe this?  Apparently there are.  This proposed DSA Utopia would quickly devolve into a hellscape.  It must be remembered that Lenin spoke of useful idiots, people who believed the Utopian pap he spouted and supported his overthrow of Russia.  After their usefulness was at an end, firing squads can eliminate them.  The DSA playbook is an old one.

Monday, October 13, 2025

The Peace Deal

It is a day for celebration.  The current war between Israel and the Palestinians has come to a conclusion, just as it has so many times before.  Where those who engineered the peace paint a rosy picture of the future, it is all too likely that this is just a lull in the eternal struggle.  Hamas shall lie low for a few years as it recruits more fodder and assembles a new arsenal, same as always.  This is only an extended ceasefire; to think otherwise is to have no knowledge of the region's history.

Then again, the peace between Israel and Egypt has held for nearly a half century.  The Abraham Accords have normalized relations between Israel and several Muslim Arab countries.  The peace process may not be the chimera it has long appeared to be.  It has taken decades, but progress toward regional peace is undeniable.  Would the various peace agreements have been successful without American arm-twisting?

Peace is good strategy for the time being.  Islam is conquering the West through unfettered migration.  Muslims are openly declaring their intent to overwhelm countries where they have immigrated, assuring them that Sharia Law is on the horizon.  The West is too soft to believe it, even as more and more districts of capital cities become Muslim majority.  The West celebrates the 'peace' in a distant land while strife takes root in the home country.

Sunday, May 12, 2024

History = The Victor's Story

History tells us the path that was taken to get us to where we are today.  Inevitably, that means it is the story of the victor, because we are the descendants of the victors.  That does not mean that the story of the losers isn't history, but it is less important than that of the victors.  The Confederate States of America had a constitution, but we don't study it.  Had the Confederacy won its independence, that constitution would be really important in history class today, especially in southern states.  However, the Confederacy was dissolved in 1865 and the Union was preserved.  Should we study the Confederacy ad nauseum to respect the ideals of the losing side?  There is only so much time to spend on history and delving into historical cul-de-sacs is not the best use of time.  However, in recent decades, that view is being upended.

In his book, Lies My Teacher Told Me, James Loewen argues for including the stories of all the losers.  Now, being a loser does not mean you were in the wrong.  Losers can be innocent victims, like the American Indian.  Stone Age tribes meet Enlightenment powers and are inevitably displaced.  It is a tragedy for the displaced tribes.  Even those that sought to integrates were forced onto reservations.  However, beyond place names and tribal casinos, this has little impact on the US of today.  Again, that's tragic, but what do Stone Age tribesmen have to teach a culture that is literally thousands of years ahead of them?  If an alien race arrives in orbit around Earth, the human race will suffer the same fate as the American Indians, no matter how much we write histories that say it wasn't fair.

Though history is written by the victor, the history of the losers has never been better recorded than today.  As a historian, I think that's terrific, but it should not be used as cause for relitigating history.  We can't give back land to the Mohicans without taking it from people today who had no part in the theft from more than 200 years ago.  Who gets Palestine?  The Palestinian Arabs, Israel, Egypt, Jordan, the British, the Ottomans, the Crusader Kingdoms, the Seljuk Turks, the Byzantines, the Romans, the Seleucids, the Achaemenids, the Assyrians, the Israelites, or the Canaanites?  The land has been ruled by all these groups and more.  Which one has the best claim?  How long does the claim hold?

As luck would have it, Western Civilization is in decline and all these losers might rise again.  When the roles reverse - notably in Europe - don't expect the new elites to care that Europe used to be the land of the whites.  Those civilizations don't hold Enlightenment values.

Thursday, January 6, 2022

The Little Drummer Girl

There is a Palestinian bomber targeting Jews in Europe.  His most recent attack in Germany missed its target but killed a young boy and maimed his mother.  Martin Kurtz, an Israeli intelligence officer, arrives to investigate.  He learns that the bomb was delivered by a college-aged Scandinavian blonde who claimed to be friends with the vacationing Swedish nanny.  Other bombings had similarly made use of attractive European women to deliver bombs.  Meanwhile in Greece, Charmian "Charlie" Ross and her band of actors were on vacation after touring the stages of England.  Charlie was a particularly talented actress who also had a history of extreme leftist politics.  Charlie and her group take note of a handsome man who is rather standoffish; he's this fascinating mystery that they want to solve.  Everyone tries to impress Joseph and he eventually consents to fraternize.  In fact, Joseph is an Israeli operative who recruits Charlie to infiltrate the bomb operation and allow Kurtz and him to eliminate Khalil, the bomb mastermind.

I had not read John Le Carre until now and I'm indifferent to his style.  The story is great, but he more often tells than shows.  He sketches his characters by offering a flurry of vignettes that paint the character.  It's like a literary montage.  I found this mostly distracting.  Nothing is happening, I'm just being told a random collection of things to outline a character.  It's not just a sentence or two, but an outline of relationships, past incidents, various noteworthy events, revealed attitudes and opinions, and so forth tossed like a mixed salad.  The first few chapters of the book were full of this as characters were introduced, giving it a glacial pace.  Of course, once that is done, the pace improves somewhat.  However, these montages also happen when a character stays in one place for a while.  Yes, now there are small events to outline to show the character of the area, be it a quiet street in a German town or a Palestinian camp in Lebanon.  There are long sequences of minutia, such as Kurtz portraying an American movie producer with Charlie's London agent in order to procure samples of her correspondence and handwriting.  This is key to being able to forge her convincingly.  On the one hand, I appreciate the attention to detail.  On the other, there is a lot more of the genial drunk theatrical agent than you would expect in a spy novel.  There is very little action but loads of tension.  Often, the stakes seem massive on the next sentence a character might utter.  Was that the right thing to say?  Will the character ruin everything with a misstatement, a verbal faux pas?  There are more often battles of words than bullets.

Charlie is the book.  Recruited by Israelis, she has her leftist politics demolished during her 'audition' and finds that many of her beliefs are rooted in sand.  She is soon won to the Israeli cause and gladly joins this 'theater of the real' to test the limits of her acting chops.  The curtain never falls and the stakes get increasingly bigger as she consents to each escalation of her involvement.  Once deep undercover, she finds herself siding with the beleaguered Palestinians.  She has sunk so deep into her role that she often believes she had a love affair with a dead terrorist and longs to kill Zionists to avenge him.  It is no wonder she convinces the Arabs of her sincerity, since she believes it herself.  Can she hold herself together to the end or will she finally crack as her Israeli and Palestinian views drive her insane?  Though I felt for Charlie, I didn't particularly like her.

Overall, a solid book and a good spy thriller.