When someone claims that an election was hacked, what does that mean? The most reasonable interpretation would be that someone either changed the votes or altered the counting of the votes via a computer. Did the Russians access computers in Michigan, Wisconsin, and Pennsylvania? No. Did they somehow hack into the machines that tally the vote counts and transfer some Hillary votes to Trump? No. So, the most reasonable interpretation of "The Russians hacked the election" is completely wrong. What did the Russians do?
The Russians managed to hack DNC servers and also access John Podesta's email. They released this data to WikiLeaks (WikiLeaks denies that Russians were the source, but they would be required to deny anyone to protect their sources). WikiLeaks then started posting it and it had an impact on the election. The Clinton Campaign did not respond to the veracity of the leaked emails but rather attacked the source of them. So, it's all true but you shouldn't have them.
However, if you are going to get all huffy about another country trying to fiddle with your elections, maybe you shouldn't be doing the same. For instance, Obama helped fund the opposition to Netanyahu in Israel. His administration was transparently hostile to Netanyahu. This is how we were treating an ally but we should demand that a foe not do something similar to us? Was the election hacked when the New York Times published Trump's 1995 tax return or was that just good reporting? If something harming a Republican - say the Pentagon Papers - is released, the leaker is celebrated. But if information harmful to Democrats is released, let's attack the source - WikiLeaks, Russia, Ed Snowden, etc.
As a geopolitical foe, we should expect Russia to attempt to influence our elections to best benefit them. I trust that our intelligence agencies are doing their best to influence our foes' politics for the best interests of America. It is the governments' job on both ends to prevent the other. Who was on watch for us during this recent hacking? Rather than blaming Trump and declaring his election illegitimate, should we not be looking squarely at our failed cyber security strategy?
No comments:
Post a Comment