Showing posts with label NASA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NASA. Show all posts

Saturday, April 4, 2026

Back to the Moon

Artemis II launched on April 1st.  No joke!  As of now, it is halfway to the moon.  It will flyby the moon and come back to earth.  This is a watered-down repeat of Apollo 8, which saw Frank Borman, Jim Lovell, and William Anders circle the moon in Christmas 1968.  While the Artemis will just slingshot around the moon and come straight back, Apollo 8 went into orbit around the moon.  However, Artemis will go farther from earth than any craft has ever gone.

This mission is long overdue.  Had NASA pulled it off on the 50th anniversary of Apollo 8, all of the named astronauts were still around.  All have since died in their 90s.  Perhaps Jared Isaacman, the new NASA Administrator, will turn the moribund agency around.  He has been to space twice, both times with SpaceX.  Let's hope he brings some of that energy and innovation into NASA.

Sunday, August 25, 2024

Starliner: End of the Line

The Boeing Starliner space capsule launched in early June for a weeklong test flight to the International Space Station (ISS).  Almost three months later, it remains docked to the station on account of safety concerns.  The two astronauts will be returning to earth via a SpaceX Dragon capsule in February.  This is the latest catastrophic failure of the Boeing spacecraft.  Years of development and troubleshooting and it is still not ready for use.  There is something seriously wrong at Boeing if it is still having issues.  It has been two years since the last flight (May 2022) revealed thruster issues, but now it has thruster issues.  Really?  NASA should kill the program.

Time to switch to the Dream Chaser.  The spaceplane designed by Sierra Space is far more versatile and is well on its way to completion.  If all goes well, it will do its first orbital flight next year.  That is probably sooner than the Starliner will be ready for yet another test flight.

Sunday, August 2, 2020

Splashdown

The Endeavor has landed in the Gulf of Mexico, completing the Demo-2 mission.  The US has a new spacecraft in the rotation.  Like the shuttle, there are a lot of reusable parts to reduce costs.  The shuttle had a 30 year run (1981 to 2011) with 135 launches, which averages a flight every 81 days.  Impressive when you consider the 2 year hiatus after each disaster.  The average cost per astronaut on the shuttle was $170 million while the Dragon comes in at a comparatively cheap $55 million per astronaut. Triple the astronauts and $5 million in savings for the same funding. Better still, now that we don't need to hitch a ride on the Russian Soyuz for $80 million per astronaut, we deny Putin another source of income.

The Crew-1 mission with 4 astronauts will launch in September and the Crew-2 mission in February. The American space program has returned to manned missions! It's about time.

Sunday, May 31, 2020

Back to Space

After a 9 year hiatus, the US is back in business.  Thanks to the launch of the SpaceX Dragon capsule, named Endeavor, the US can stop hitching a ride on Russian rockets to reach the International Space Station.  Since the shuttle was retired, US astronauts have been using Russia's space program as a taxi service for an increasingly expensive fee.  What was a $20 million seat in 2007 had inflated to $81 million by 2016.  That's what monopoly gets you.  The price for SpaceX is going to be $55 million per astronaut, a bargain.

Next up, the SpaceX Starship!  Or maybe something from Blue Origin.  Or maybe Virgin Galactic.  It is the dawning of a golden age in manned spaceflight.

Wednesday, May 10, 2017

Generational Attitudes toward Government

On a recent EconTalk, Russ Roberts interviewed Tyler Cowan.  Cowan's latest book is The Complacent Class: The Self-Defeating Quest for the American Dream.  He posits that a slow down in social change, a diminishing mobility, and a growing aversion to risk is causing the US to become less innovative and productive.  It is a really fascinating discussion and recommended.
 
What really got me thinking was a comment he made about how Millennials have a very different cultural view of government:
 
So, whereas I grew up with the space program, which put a man on the moon, maybe they grew up with the second Iraq War or the Financial Crisis.
 
This is a significant observation that deserves deeper consideration.  The government won praise for its successes and was trusted with more tasks based on those successes.  However, a string of failures is what has followed and yet the government wants to be trusted to do even more.  It cannot accomplish the basic tasks of government (e.g. maintain the borders, balance the budget, win wars, etc.) but still wants more money and authority to do even more.  Where are the great successes to justify more responsibility?  Republicans blame Democrats, Democrats blame Republicans but the end result is continued failures and poor governance which is always explained away by intransigence by the other party.  BS!  Based on performance, the scope of the federal government should be severely curtailed.
 
The greatest success of the Obama years was his neglect of NASA.  At first, I was aghast even though the dynamism of NASA from the 1960s has ossified into a bureaucracy that hasn't been able to put an astronaut in space since 2011.  But I didn't see other options.  Then SpaceX, Virgin Galactic, and Blue Origin started launching rockets and developing new technologies.  Spacecraft haven't been this exciting since the Apollo Program.  More of government would benefit from the NASA treatment.

Saturday, February 25, 2017

The Sad State of NASA

In the wake of the Columbia Disaster (February 1, 2003), it was determined that the space shuttle would be retired by 2010 and would thus need a replacement.  The initial replacement was the Constellation Program (begun in 2005) with the goal of launching astronauts into space by 2014.  President Obama cancelled the Constellation Program in 2009.  The Space Launch System (SLS) was started in 2010, replacing the Constellation Program.  The last space shuttle mission was flown in July of 2011.  This article has NASA putting astronauts in space in 2019 at the soonest but more likely 2021, a ten year gap in manned NASA launches.  So, knowing that the shuttle needed a successor, NASA will have spent 16 years to make it (2005 to 2021).
 
On October 4, 1957, the Soviet Union launched Sputnik and the Space Race.  Project Mercury saw its first rocket test on August 21, 1959.  Called Little Joe 1, it was a failure.  By December of that year, Sam the chimpanzee was launched into space.  In May of 1961, Alan Shepard became the first American in space.  NASA knew that Mercury was just the beginning and had the two-man capsules of Gemini ready for a test launch (April 1964) less than a year after the last Mercury rocket launched (May 1963).  The first Gemini manned mission was in May 1965.  Gemini wrapped up its 10 manned mission run in November of 1966.  In January 1967, the Apollo Program suffered a disastrous fire on the launch pad, killing 3 astronauts.  Even with the disaster, Apollo 7 launched in October of the following year.  Apollo 11 was on the moon in July 1969, less than 10 years since Little Joe 1.  Apollo 17 was the last moon landing.  Remaining rockets for further moon missions were used for Skylab, which was launched in May 1973.  The last of the Apollo rockets was used for the Apollo-Soyuz test in July 1975, which saw US astronauts shake hands with Soviet Cosmonauts in space.  US spaceflight ended until the shuttle was ready.  US spaceflight resumed on April 14, 1981, a gap of just under 6 years.  To duplicate that, we would need to launch astronauts in the next two months.
 
Clearly, NASA does not enjoy the budget it had during the 1960s but modern technology should dramatically reduce the costs and development time.  Really, if you have seen Hidden Figures in which all the calculations were done by hand with pencil, paper, and slide rules, how can progress not go much faster?  Instead, it is taking vastly longer to do things that we were doing more than 40 years ago.  NASA has suffered the fate of most government bureaucracies.  When it began, it had a purpose and clear goals.  Today it has an organizational chart and a budget.  Rather than having projects that need to get done, they are trying to find things to do, to keep busy, to defend their funding.

Sunday, January 8, 2017

Hidden Figures

The movie opens with a very young Katherine Goble getting accepted to a prestigious school because she is a math whiz.  Thirty years later, she (Taraji Henson) and two other women - Dorothy Vaughan (Octavia Spencer) and Mary Jackson (Janelle Monae) - are stranded on the side of the road with a broken down car.  A police officer shows up and demands ID and is generally unfriendly.  However, once they explain they work at NASA, he proves willing to provide an escort.  At NASA, the three are members of the West Area Computers (at the time, a computer was just a person who did calculations with pen and paper or an old-fashioned mechanical calculator).  Dorothy is the unofficial supervisor of the colored computers, Katherine is the most brilliant mathematician among them, and Mary is attracted to engineering.

Except for the prologue of Katherine as a child, the movie compresses events into a 1 year window, opening a few months before Al Shepard's Mercury flight in May 1961 and ending with John Glenn's orbit in February 1962.  That's fine except that events well outside of that period are included.  Thus, we get incidents that date 10 years back.  Because of this, a lot of real people were replaced by fictional versions, otherwise some of this would be libelous.

For instance, the Space Task Group was run by Robert Gilruth but he is replaced by the fictional Al Harrison (Kevin Costner).  The designer of the Mercury capsule was Max Faget but he is replaced by the fictional Karl Zielinski.  What little we learn of Zielinski is that he is Polish and his parents were killed by the Nazis during the war.  Is he supposed to be a replacement for Wehrner Von Braun, the former Nazi rocket scientist who was integral to the US Space Program?  Certainly more politically correct to have a Polish Jew.

White characters are uniformly racist.  Only three white characters are painted as other than racist: Al Harrison, Karl Zielinski, and John Glenn (Glen Powell).  The scene where Harrison "discovers" that the engineers had setup a separate 'colored' coffee pot for Katherine was particularly egregious.  He only just now discovered it?  Doesn't he drink coffee?  He has glass as his office wall and the coffee table is easily visible.  His righteously indignant speech followed by his ripping down of the colored ladies room sign was completely unbelievable.  Segregation at Langley ended in 1958, outside the timeframe of the movie.
 
According to the film, it is only thanks to the mathematical talents of Katherine Johnson that we were able to orbit the earth.  I have no doubt that she was an integral figure but she is shown to be so much smarter than this room full of brilliant mathematicians and engineers as to be silly.  She is the sine qua non of American Space Flight.  Jim Parsons had the role of playing an arrogant, probably racist, jerk who, despite being embarrassed by her math talents repeatedly, continued to look down his nose at her.  However, by the end, he shows he has gained some respect for her.  Yes, black women can do math too.  Ugh.  Of course, her life events from the 50s (promotion out of the West Area Computers, marriage to Jim Johnson, desegregation of Langley) were all included.

The storyline of Dorothy Vaughn is done so ham-fistedly that I cringed.  NASA has purchased IBM computers and the half dozen white men who are supposed to operate them are utterly clueless.  They can't get the mainframe to do anything.  Meanwhile, Dorothy gets a book from the library (the racist librarian called the cops to eject her and her two sons!) on Fortran, reads it, and schools these white doofuses in how to work the IBM.  She was promoted to her unofficial supervisor position in 1949, not 1960 as the movie implies.
 
Oddly enough, though she was probably the least addressed of the trio, Mary Jackson's story arc was the best.  Her success required that she get advanced training available only at a segregated high school.  She took her case to court, made a strong argument to the judge, won her case, and started attending classes to qualify for an engineering position at NASA.  Of course, she had made her move out of the West Area Computers in 1953, not 1961.  Also, she had completed her advanced training in the 50s.

Yeah, I get it, segregation was wrong.  Worse, much of the dialogue is written as a social justice warrior would write it.  Katherine smacks down Jim's sexist comment like a 70s feminist rather than the mousy mathematician she is otherwise portrayed to be.  Katherine's explosive rant in the middle of the office was about as bad a reaction on the part of an employee as imaginable in reaction to the horrible job of management by Harrison.  Meant to be dramatic, I just shook my head and rolled my eyes.  That is a fictional scene from the mind of the screenwriter.  We needed to spice it up, add some drama, more tension!  Yeah, right.  Dorothy undiplomatically rejects her supervisor's (Kirsten Dunst) claim that she's not a racist.  Shortly thereafter, Dunst arrives - almost cap in hand-like - to ask if Dorothy would be so kind as to teach Fortran to the white lady computers.  Be humbled, you racist bat!

The movie does give an accurate 'feel' for the flow of each woman's life but is forced to fictionalize a lot of the setting.  Katherine Johnson, Dorothy Vaughan, and Mary Jackson were amazing women of remarkable accomplishment but this movie spends more time picking at the scabs of racism and sexism rather than celebrating their talents.  Fine, we need some context for the era but the context doesn't need to be repeated every 5 minutes.  Because it mixes fiction with fact and tinkered with the timeline, I don't know what to believe.

Skip the movie but check the links to each of the three impressive women who contributed to the American Space Program.

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Monkeys to Mars

The Russians are training an elite team of rhesus monkeys to travel to the red planet and land sometime in 2017.  And so began the Planet of the Monkeys!

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3291456/Monkeys-heading-MARS-Russian-scientists-training-macaques-solve-puzzles-travel-space-2017.html

I think it is laughable that it is 'unclear' if the monkeys will return.  Duh!  Of course the monkeys won't be returning.  The Russians weren't too concerned about Laika, the first dog in space.  Heck, the Russians lost several cosmonauts during the Space Race thanks to their comparatively lax safety standards.  Best case scenario is that one or two of the monkeys remain on an orbiter while the others land on Mars.  The ones who land are there to stay.  Those on the orbiter might make a return trip to determine the requirements of such a trip.  The logistics of keeping the monkeys alive and well for a trip to and from Mars seem daunting.  Will they be trained not to throw poop on the control panel?
 
We've landed probes and rovers on Mars and have had orbiters map Mars.  The next logical step is getting living creatures there.  The Russians have no experience beyond Low Earth Orbit (LEO), so this is more necessary for them than for the US.  Still, the Russians are planning a big space program while NASA can't even get its astronauts to the International Space Station (ISS) without hitching a ride on a Russian Soyuz.
 
I went to the Houston Space Center several years ago and saw amazing things and heard about impressive plans.  That was five years ago.  Five years after Kennedy called for America to put a man on the moon, we had completed Project Mercury and were wrapping up Gemini.  Today, we don't even have a vessel for our astronauts to fly.  The closest thing is the SpaceX Dragon which is currently delivering supplies to the ISS.  Yes, we can't get monkeys in space but the Russians are going to send some to Mars.  Who won the Space Race?  Who won the Cold War?
 

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Obama Success

Yes, Obama has had a success and I had thought it was a massive blunder at the time.  I vented my irritation at the President in a blog post.  However, events have come to pass that show great promise at lower cost.  No, not Obamacare but space exploration.

When NASA's Constellation Project was slashed so the president could expand the food stamp program and his doomed Stimulus, I was aghast.  The US had space superiority and now we were hitching rides on Russian Soyuz capsules.  The US space program looked to be a casualty of Obama's spending priorities.  As it happens, the private space companies are making leaps and bounds.  SpaceX is the standout with its Falcon rocket and Dragon space capsule; SpaceX is running resupply missions to the International Space Station (ISS) and will soon be able to shuttle astronauts for a fraction of the price of the space shuttles.  Orbital Science Corporation (OSC) is a big player in satellites but is aiming to also resupply the ISS with its Cygnus spacecraft.

What is truly funny about this is it fits what I have long said about most issues: get the government out and the prices will drop and more will get accomplished.  How did I end up on the wrong side of this argument?  Mostly, it is because space is still a government domain.  Even all this private activity is funded through government contracts.  Getting into space and bringing back something of value is still a ways off.  This is why space tourism is likely to be the first moneymaker for private companies (e.g. Virgin Galactic).  Eventually, we'll see mining operations on the moon and then elsewhere but that is still beyond the market.  But not for long.

The Mars One project has a hundred thousand volunteers to migrate to the red planet in 2023.  It would be a one way trip and yet there are plenty of applicants.  Even the founder of SpaceX, Elon Musk, plans to die on Mars.

Here is the interesting point: Obama's success is a case where he defunded a government agency and let the private market take over.  This is precisely the opposite of what he has done with health care, the car companies, banks, mortgages, student loans, etc.  While all of these are seeing rising costs, NASA is seeing a drop in the price of resupply missions.  Perhaps the president could learn from this.

Saturday, August 25, 2012

Neil Armstrong, RIP

The first man to set foot on the moon has died.  Neil Armstrong landed on the moon in July of 1969 when I was 2 years old and Nixon was 6 months into his first term.  The last moon landing took place in December of 1972 when I was 5 and Nixon was finishing his first term.  No one has gone beyond low earth orbit since then.

President George W. Bush proposed to go to Mars and the Constellation program was born.  The plan was to return to capsules - like Mercury, Gemini, and Apollo - when the shuttle was retired.  We would return to the moon as a way station to Mars.  In the wake of the financial panic of 2008 and the funding issues of government, Obama canceled Constellation in 2010.  Rather than the moon, we could perhaps try for an asteroid.  Much as I admire cutting government budgets, it is hard to swallow when the President found nearly a trillion dollars for his failed stimulus and has run trillion dollar deficits every year he has been President.  NASA's budget is around $20 billion a year, a pittance.

I have often said that government does not invest but, in the case of NASA, I may be wrong.  The technological achievements of the space program brought a great many new products to the consumer, Tang being the least of them.  Certainly, NASA has more long term benefits than food stamps ($71 billion) or Ethanol subsidies ($6 billion).

Neil Armstrong and many other astronauts from the Golden Age of the US Space Program spoke out in opposition to Obama's plan to dump Constellation.  Armstrong, who became something of a recluse after he left NASA, was a rarity on the national stage so his comments on this had added weight.  Nonetheless, Constellation was ended.
 
The US had unquestioned dominance in space and it has been abandoned.  SpaceX and its Dragon may provide another means to get to the International Space Station but the moon and Mars are unlikely in the near future.  Whereas Columbus was followed by the likes of Drake, Magellan, and Cook, Armstrong and the Apollo astronauts have seen 40 years of nothing.  The giants of the US Space Program are dying and there is no one to replace them.

Friday, May 25, 2012

Catch a Dragon by the Tail

The US is back in space.  SpaceX, a private space agency, launched the Dragon capsule this week on a Falcon rocket.  Today, the capsule intercepted the International Space Station (ISS) and docked.  Less than a year after the Shuttle was retired, NASA has an alternative route to space.  Dragon is not expected to transport crew until 2016, so it is just an unmanned resupply vessel for the time being. Thus, US Astronauts must still use the Soyuz at $63 million a flight thanks to the Russian monopoly on manned spaceflight.

Pleased as I am, this is low earth orbit (LEO) stuff but it doesn't touch what we were doing 40 years ago.  SpaceX can be a great competitor for the Russian Soyuz but it's not Apollo.  The Constellation program was supposed to get us back to the moon and beyond but that has been scrapped.  Yes, money is tight but retiring the shuttle (very expensive each launch) and using a private contractor for ISS resupply (much cheaper) should allow for the restart of Constellation.

The entire space program from 1959 to 1973 cost $109 billion (adjusted for inflation for 2010 dollars), roughly an eighth of the 2009 Stimulus.  NASA's current budget is $18 billion a year (0.5% of the federal budget), which is less than the Department of Energy.  DOE has done a great job, tossing taxpayer dollars into wonderful 'investments' like Solyndra (bankrupt), NRG Energy (Bankrupt), and Abound Solar (laying off workers).  Or how about the Department of Homeland Security, which has a $55 billion budget.  I would be fine with abolishing that department altogether - especially TSA.  Use half the cash for deficit reduction and the rest for NASA, provided NASA returns to space exploration and drops the Muslim outreach.

Monday, April 16, 2012

SpaceX to the International Space Station

SpaceX, the private space transport company, is going to the space station. Having won a contract from NASA to resupply the space station, SpaceX is sending an unmanned Dragon spacecraft on its first mission to do so. In December of 2010, the Dragon was successfully launched into orbit and returned to earth. This time, if all goes well, it will dock with the space station and deliver food and equipment. In the near future, it could become a competitor to the Russian Soyuz capsule that now has a monopoly on ferrying astronauts to and from the space station. America might get back in space, thanks to a private firm. The SpaceX website is great fun for the space enthusiast.

http://www.spacex.com/

The Dragon is an impressive craft, designed to transport up to 7 astronauts. It also has integrated rockets that can bring it to a safe landing in case of emergency, an improvement over the Launch Escape System of Apollo. It is strange to see a return to capsules after decades of shuttle launches. However, the capsule is both cheaper and safer, which might provide for a more robust space program at much lower cost. Let us hope.